Deductible and Improvements

Texas Homeowners Replacement Cost Policy

Understanding Free Improvements from Your Contractor: A Texas Policyholder’s Guide

Imagine your home in Bedford, Texas, just took a hit from a storm—maybe a hail-damaged roof or busted windows. You file a claim under your replacement cost homeowners insurance policy, and a contractor offers to fix it up, tossing in some "free improvements" like fancier shingles or an extra vent. Sounds great, right? But as a Texas homeowner, you need to know the rules to keep everything above board. Here’s the details of how it works, with an outline to guide you.

I. The Basics of Your Insurance Claim

Your Policy’s Promise: Your replacement cost policy is designed to bring your home back to its pre-storm condition with new materials. The insurance company pays for repairs or replacements, but there’s a catch—you’ve got a deductible (say, $1,000) you’re responsible for out of pocket. Once repairs are done, they might even cover depreciation costs, but only if everything’s legit.

The Contractor’s Role: A contractor steps in to do the work, using the insurance payout (minus your deductible) to cover the costs they bill for. So far, so good.

II. The Offer of "Free Improvements"

What They Might Look Like: Picture this—the contractor says, "Hey, I’ll throw in premium shingles instead of the standard ones, or add a skylight, all on me—no extra charge!" These are promotional freebies, like a bonus for choosing their service.

The Big Question: Is this legal in Texas? Spoiler: Yes, it can be—but only if everyone plays by the rules.

III. Texas Rules You Need to Know

Rule #1: You Must Pay Your Deductible (Texas Insurance Code § 707.002)

The state says you’ve got to pay that $1,000 deductible, no exceptions. It’s the law since 2019—contractors can’t waive it or sneakily cover it for you. If your contractor’s "free improvements" don’t mess with this, you’re in the clear. You write that check or swipe your card, and the insurance money covers the rest of the covered repairs.

Rule #2: No Inflating the Claim

The insurance claim has to be honest. The contractor can’t jack up the bill—say, claiming $12,000 for a $10,000 repair job—just to hide the cost of those fancy shingles. The claim should only cover what’s needed to fix your home to its pre-storm state, nothing more. If the improvements come out of the contractor’s own pocket, not the insurance payout, it’s all good.

Rule #3: Clear Paperwork (Texas Business & Commerce Code § 27.02)

Your contract with the contractor has to spell out in big, bold letters that you’re paying the deductible. It’s a legal must for any job over $1,000 tied to insurance money. The "free improvements" should be listed separately—like a little thank-you note—so there’s no confusion about what the insurance is actually paying for.

IV. How It Plays Out

The Happy Path: Let’s say your roof repair costs $10,000. You pay your $1,000 deductible, the insurance sends $9,000, and the contractor uses that to fix the roof. Then, as a promo, they toss in $500 worth of upgraded shingles from their own funds. You get a nicer roof, the contractor looks like a hero, and the insurance company is content—because they don’t care about extras you didn’t claim.

The Red Flag Path: If the contractor says, "Don’t worry about the deductible, I’ll cover it with these freebies," or pads the claim to sneak in the upgrades, that’s trouble. Texas law could slap them with fines, and you might get tangled up in a fraud mess. Nobody wants that.

V. Keeping It Safe and Legal

Ask Questions: When the contractor offers freebies, ask, "Am I still paying my deductible? Is this coming out of your pocket, not the insurance?" Get it in writing—something like, "Promotional upgrade: $500 shingles, no cost to homeowner."

Check with Your Insurer: Before the work’s done, make sure the insurance adjuster’s cool with the repair plan. They’ll want proof you paid the deductible anyway, so keep that receipt handy.

Know Your Rights: If something smells fishy—like the contractor’s dodging the deductible talk—call the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI). They’re there to help you sort it out.

VI. The Bottom Line

In Texas, your contractor can legally sweeten the deal with free improvements if:

You pay your deductible in full (no shortcuts!).

The insurance claim sticks to the real repair costs, no fluff.

The extras come from the contractor’s wallet, not your insurance check.

It’s like getting a free dessert with your meal—nice, as long as you still paid for the main course. Enjoy the upgrade, but keep it clean and legal, and you’ll sleep easy knowing your home’s fixed right.

Key Takeaway

By following this guide, you’ve learned that Texas law protects you and your insurer by keeping claims honest. Your contractor’s free improvements are a bonus you can enjoy, but only if you pay your share (the deductible) and the insurance money stays focused on the repairs it’s meant for. Next time a contractor pitches something "free," you’ll know the rules to keep it legit!